Stacie and I’ve been long-time ButcherBox members, happening 7 years now. The primary time we’d ever heard of ButcherBox was whereas attending a convention in Austin, TX in 2017 after we in some way discovered ourselves in a shuttle with the corporate’s founders when it was pouring rain and we would have liked a journey again to our lodge room. As we made dialog alongside the way in which we couldn’t assist however discover how passionate they have been about what they have been constructing with their meat subscription service. We knew then that we simply needed to study extra and test them out for ourselves.
Quick ahead greater than seven years and we’re now avid customers of this subscription service that delivers prime quality meat, poultry, seafood and extra to our doorsteps every month. Since then, Jessie has additionally turn out to be a ButcherBox member and he or she too enjoys the standard and comfort the service gives.
On this evaluate I’ll be sharing extra about what ButcherBox is, why it’s completely different from different grocery supply companies, their deal with high quality, the comfort, and the associated fee that will help you determine if ButcherBox is an efficient match for you.
However earlier than we soar proper into what we consider ButcherBox let me fill you in on what it’s. Put merely, ButcherBox is a meat subscription service that delivers 100% grass-fed and grass-finished beef, natural rooster and turkey, wild-caught fish and seafood, heritage breed pork, and extra to your door every month (or as usually as you want). Additionally they provide one-time buy reward bins which you could ship to pals or household.
Need to save this web page?
Enter your electronic mail beneath & we’ll ship it straight to your inbox. Plus you’ll get nice new recipes from us each week!
Our Verdict
After 7 years of getting meat and seafood delivered to our doorways, listed below are our takes on ButcherBox.
General – Our group of dietitians all agree that ButcherBox meats and seafood are actually prime quality. The meat and pork are undoubtedly on par with the very best quality meat accessible in our native grocery shops, if not higher. The rooster, whereas handy to have delivered, is roughly the identical high quality because the natural rooster we purchase domestically. That stated, all of us benefit from the boneless, skinless rooster issues so we do add these to each field. Along with the entire muscle cuts (steaks, chops, roasts) and floor beef, we’ve all been having fun with the expanded line of precooked or comfort choices ButcherBox now gives.
Jessica – I completely love the standard of their grass-fed floor beef and floor sirloin, steaks, and pork. Having a number of cuts and kinds of meat, poultry and seafood available in my freezer makes meal planning, prepping, and cooking a lot simpler. After I plan our meals, I begin by ‘procuring’ my chest freezer to seek out the lower(s) I wish to use, then construct the meals from there. These days, I’ve additionally appreciated the wide range of pre-cooked proteins like carnitas, rooster breakfast sausage patties, and rooster nuggets as a result of I’ve youngsters and these are simple for them to arrange themselves. A few of the different cuts I at all times preserve available embrace floor sirloin, flank steak, wild-caught Alaskan sockeye salmon, free-range boneless, skinless rooster thighs, and boneless thick-cut pork chops.
Stacie – As a mother of three youngsters ages 4 and below I worth comfort and ease over most something nowadays. However it nonetheless must be wholesome so I’ve discovered the frozen meatballs, rooster nuggets, precooked rooster breast, and egg bites to be so useful for these nights and weekends once I must get a meal on the desk with minimal fuss. Plus, they style nice and my youngsters love them. In fact, I additionally love the standard of the bottom beef and turkey and their pork chops, child again ribs, and pork shoulders are among the greatest I’ve ever tried. Our household purchases half of a cow from an area farm annually so we get most of our steaks and roasts there however I do love the ButcherBox steaks too. The ribeyes and filet mignon are a few of my favorites.
Jessie – I’m additionally a mother of three and a spouse of a firefighter so I’ve a number of nights every week the place I’m by myself to spherical up dinner. Now that I’m additionally teaching my son’s baseball group, time is even tighter, so I usually flip to the precooked choices that ButcherBox has to supply, just like the meatballs, apple gouda sausages, cooked carnitas, and rooster nuggets. However for these nights when our whole household eats collectively, I prefer to make a meal from scratch. A few of my go-tos in each field are floor beef, boneless skinless rooster breasts and thighs, sirloin suggestions, smoked salmon, boneless pork butt (for the gradual cooker), and child again ribs (for a scrumptious night time on the smoker-grill).
Execs And Cons
After having used this service for over seven years, these are the professionals and cons that we’ve provide you with that will help you determine if ButcherBox is an efficient match for you.
| Execs | Cons |
| Excessive-quality cuts of meat, poultry and seafood in keeping with the most effective cuts accessible at native grocery shops. | Packaging can generally tear throughout transport because of the very low temperatures that the meat is frozen at. This may trigger the packages to leak when thawed. |
| Giant number of beef, pork, and poultry cuts accessible. Sometimes there are over 25 cuts to select from. | Choices can change so you could not at all times be capable of get the identical cuts each month in case you have a customized field. |
| Curated field picks fluctuate month to month so that you get publicity to new cuts of meat. | Curated field picks change so that you don’t at all times get the identical cuts every month. |
| No extra having to buy a number of shops to seek out the standard meat, poultry and seafood in your space as a result of it comes proper to your door. | Price is greater than common grocery shops or huge field shops for related cuts (although the standard might not be the identical). |
| ButcherBox sources its meat and seafood from ranchers, farmers and fishermen and girls who’re devoted to doing the correct factor for the animal, the employees, and the setting. | Price per serving is greater than your native grocery retailer in some instances due to the deal with sourcing and high quality. |
| Packing is 100% recyclable in lots of city and suburban areas through curbside recycling and recycling facilities. | Packaging, whereas constituted of recyclable supplies, might not be settle for for recycling in your space. |
What Comes In The Packing containers?
There are two kinds of bins to select from: curated (they select for you) and customized (you select your cuts). Each varieties are provided in two sizes – traditional and large bins – to accommodate completely different measurement households.
Curated – Accommodates 8-11 kilos of meat (Basic measurement) or 16-22 kilos (Large field measurement) and the cuts are chosen for you. There are 3 kinds of curated bins to select from together with:
- Beef, Pork & Rooster
- Beef & Rooster
- Beef & Pork
Curated bins can be found in 2 sizes: Basic ($146) and Large Field ($269)
Customized – Accommodates 9-14 kilos of meat (Basic measurement) or 18-26 kilos (Large field measurement) and also you select your cuts. This feature offers you 20% extra meat than a curated field of the identical measurement. Benefit from the means to select from over 25 cuts every month and make adjustments to your field every month to change issues up.
Customized bins can be found in 2 sizes: Basic $169 or Large Field ($309)
Our group of dietitians go for the customized field in order that we will select the cuts we use most frequently which helps a ton with meal planning. Figuring out what we have now available within the freezer means we’re one step nearer to creating meals we all know our households love.
Does It Style Good?
What stands out most for us is the standard of the meat we get from ButcherBox. When put next side-by-side with meat from native grocery shops, we expect that the flavour is unbeatable. Whereas we love the comfort and selection this service gives, the way in which the meat tastes tops the record of causes we proceed to make use of ButcherBox to supply our meat, fish, poultry, and extra. We’re big followers of their pork. It’s among the most tender and flavorful pork we’ve ever eaten and the steaks are nicely lower, nicely trimmed and completely aged.
Taste is unquestionably one of many huge the explanation why we select ButcherBox for the meat we feed our households however we additionally imagine that meat that’s well-raised – with respect to the way it’s raised, what it eats, and the way it’s processed – is best meat. Higher for the well being of the animals, the farmers, and the setting. And naturally, higher for our households.
Are ButcherBox Meats All Grass-Fed And Natural?
All ButcherBox beef is 100% grass-fed and grass-finished which implies their cattle have been raised on pasture their whole lives. Grass-fed beef tends to be leaner than conventionally raised beef but it surely’s nonetheless extremely flavorful and it’s a superb supply of omega-3 fat. Selecting high quality purple meat is necessary to me as a mother and dietitian and this service makes it simple to do.
Whereas their beef is just not licensed natural, their rooster is USDA Licensed Natural. ButcherBox chickens are free-range and fed natural rooster feed.
Our Favourite Cuts.
Jessica – A few of my favourite cuts embrace the flatiron steaks, wild-caught Alaskan sockeye salmon, bone-in pork butt, and floor sirloin.
Stacie – Boneless rooster breasts and thighs, pork tenderloin, bone-in pork butt, boneless pork chops, and child again ribs are a few of our most ordered cuts.
Jessie – Our household loves floor beef, rooster nuggets, child again ribs, cooked beef and pork meatballs, boneless pork butt, boneless skinless rooster breasts.
Price And Worth: Is ButcherBox Price It?
The price per lower, whereas greater than what you’d pay at a giant field retailer like Costco or Walmart, is definitely similar to what you’ll discover at native grocery shops for comparable high quality. The place I dwell, I can anticipate to pay $6.99-15.99 per pound (or extra!) for grass-fed and grass-finished floor beef, natural rooster and heritage breed pork. I’ve discovered the worth of ButcherBox to be very aggressive with native pricing once I examine gadgets lower for lower – that means I’m evaluating NY Strips to NY Strips and never filet mignon to rooster drumsticks.
As a working mother who values time with my household and energetic outside pursuits, the one factor I can’t put sufficient worth on is the comfort of ButcherBox. I like having a wide range of high-quality beef, rooster, pork, seafood, and ready comfort gadgets like pre-cooked breakfast sausages and grilled rooster breasts in my freezer that I can use to arrange wholesome, scrumptious meals for my household. The very first thing I do once I meal plan every week is to go downstairs to see what I’ve received available, then I select recipes primarily based on that and make my grocery record for what I’ll want for the week.
Right here’s a breakdown of the pricing for every form of field that ButcherBox gives:
- Curated Field (Basic) – $149
- Customized Field (Basic) – $169
- Curated Field (Large) – $269
- Customized Field (Large) -$309
Whereas the customized bins are dearer than curated bins you do obtain 20% extra meat in a customized field and also you get to decide on the cuts you obtain. I like this selection – and so do Stacie and Jessie – as a result of I do know that there are cuts I take advantage of usually corresponding to floor beef and sirloin, rooster thighs, flat iron steaks, flank steak and pork butt.
Recipes We Made With ButcherBox Meats
We’ve made so many recipes with the meats we get in our month-to-month bins over the previous seven years that it could be unattainable to record all of them right here. One among my household’s favourite recipes is for these saucy beef suggestions that Jessie created which we serve over creamy mashed potatoes. And this hearty soup is certainly one of Stacie’s go-to for freezer meal preps.
Who Is ButcherBox For?
ButcherBox could also be a fantastic possibility for you should you determine with any of the next:
- You don’t have entry to high-quality meat in your space – Whether or not you reside in a rural space or an city space generally you simply don’t have entry to high-quality meat. ButcherBox fills that hole by delivering high-quality protein proper to your door. They ship all over the place within the contiguous 48 states and transport is at all times free.
- You worth comfort – We don’t should let you know this as a result of we’re fairly positive that you simply already know that procuring at a number of shops for the most effective selection and costs takes quite a lot of time! As a result of there are solely so many hours within the day, you could have to contemplate how a lot your time is price.
- You worth high quality – In the event you love a superb steak, a young rooster breast, an insanely scrumptious pork chop, or contemporary seafood and exit of your option to discover the very best quality, then ButcherBox is likely to be a fantastic match for you. They’ve completed the leg work on the subject of sourcing and solely provide the very best quality they’ll discover.
- You wish to attempt new issues – While you select a curated field from ButcherBox, they select the cuts that you simply’ll obtain. That is nice for many who have a tendency to purchase the identical cuts within the grocery retailer again and again since you’re compelled to suppose outdoors the field on the subject of meals. You can even select from all kinds of member offers and add-ons no matter the kind of field you select (curated or customized). We love this characteristic as a result of there’s at all times one thing new to try to add to our menus.
Who it’s not for
There are some for whom this service won’t be a superb match. Listed below are just a few instances that come to thoughts:
- You don’t eat meat – This most likely goes with out saying however should you don’t eat meat, ButcherBox isn’t going to be a superb match for you.
- You could have entry to locally-raised meat – In the event you elevate your personal meat, buy meat from an area farmer or rancher, or belong to a meat CSA (group supported agriculture) then ButcherBox won’t be a match for you. Nonetheless, should you solely have entry to 1 form of meat then take a look at the several types of bins ButcherBox gives. The possibilities are good that their choices are an ideal complement to what you’ll be able to supply domestically.
- You get pleasure from procuring at a number of shops to get what you want – If time is in your aspect otherwise you actually get pleasure from visiting a number of shops looking for high-quality meat and seafood then ButcherBox might not be a superb match for you. Nonetheless, if it’s the variability that you simply crave greater than the precise procuring, then we encourage you to take a look at the ButcherBox Customized field the place you possibly can select from greater than 20 completely different cuts of meat every month.
- You’re on a really tight price range – ButcherBox might not be a superb match for households with very tight grocery budgets. If, nonetheless, feeding your loved ones high-quality meat is a precedence however so is minding your month-to-month grocery price range, you possibly can maximize your funding by buying a Large Field (both curated or customized) each different month and making the most of Butcher Field’s member-only specials each time accessible. The Large Field works out to be inexpensive per pound and when supplemented with meatless meals or meat out of your native grocery retailer you would possibly discover that it really works together with your price range.
Ceaselessly Requested Questions
It’s simple to enroll and select your first field. As a result of it’s a subscription service, their default is to ship a field to your door each month however you possibly can simply change your supply date by logging into your ButcherBox account and choosing the date and frequency that works greatest for you. You can even change your field sort or field measurement, and select any one-time member offers or recurring add-ons you’d like in your subsequent field.
You’ll be able to cancel or cease your membership, with out penalties or hidden charges, anytime earlier than your subsequent billing date.
A customized huge field will provide you with the most effective worth as a result of it has 20% extra meat than a curated huge field which lowers the common value per pound by a couple of greenback. It’s quite a lot of meat (18-26 kilos) so you could want to alter your supply to obtain a field each different month if that’s an excessive amount of meat in your family every month.
ButcherBox is extremely handy and so they have quite a lot of nice choices with over 25 completely different cuts accessible. We predict that the flavour is best than many of the meat we’ve bought in native grocery shops and large field shops however what units ButcherBox aside is their consideration to sourcing.
They work with huge and small farms and are very selective in regards to the producers they permit into their applications. They rigorously vet all of their suppliers to ensure that they meet specs and claims and all operations and services are routinely inspected to keep up the best high quality. They additionally depend on third-party audits from organizations like Licensed Humane and World Animal Partnership (GAP).
Like something you might have delivered to your house, your ButcherBox will include packaging. Nonetheless, the excellent news is that the packaging is 100% recyclable in lots of areas. The cardboard field and fiber-based insulation could be positioned proper into your curbside recycling bin whereas the plastic bag that the dry ice is available in could be taken to your native recycling heart or a grocery retailer that has a bag recycling drop-off. Contact your native recycling heart for extra details about what you possibly can and can’t recycle in your space.
ButcherBox doesn’t supply any of its meat from China. Once they began in 2015 they sourced all of their grass-fed beef from Australia which has a complete system constructed particularly for certifying pasture-raised meat. Australia additionally has very excessive animal welfare requirements in addition to the local weather and pastureland to permit cattle to spend their whole lives grazing.
As of 2024 ButcherBox continues to supply nearly all of its beef from Australia (80%) with the remaining 20% coming from the USA. Their continued funding within the U.S. grass-fed beef business to assist and develop sustainability and scalability efforts is another excuse we love ButcherBox.
Their pork and rooster come from the U.S. and Canada, and different proteins corresponding to wild-caught Alaskan sockeye salmon, wild-caught cod, bison, and turkey all come from the U.S.
Options To ButcherBox
Whereas ButcherBox was one of many first meat subscriptions on the market they aren’t the one one. Listed below are just a few others that come to thoughts. However please observe that we have now not tried any of them so we will’t communicate to their worth or high quality.
- Good Chop – This service is similar to ButcherBox in that it’s a subscription service, the number of cuts and merchandise are related, additionally they have month-to-month member offers and recurring add-ons and so they provide bins in two sizes. All of their meat and seafood is sourced from the U.S. The large distinction, nonetheless, is that their beef is just not grass-fed and grass-finished (it’s grain-finished) and the poultry is just not natural. The costs seem like comparable.
- Primal Pastures – Like ButcherBox, this meat subscription service gives pasture-raised beef and natural, pastured corn- and soy-free meats. The worth is corresponding to ButcherBox and transport is obtainable nationwide. To make adjustments to your supply date, you do must contact them through electronic mail to make that request. You’ll be able to select which kinds of protein you’d like in your field (beef, rooster, or pork) however you can not select particular cuts (just like the curated bins from ButcherBox).
- Crimson Star Beef – If it’s solely grass-fed and grass-finished beef from the U.S. that you simply’re in search of, this meat subscription service could also be a superb possibility for you. Positioned in Loma, CO, they provide curated and customized bins in two sizes plus the power to make one-time purchases.
